You have good points
I would argue it matters on the use case…
Shopify
Pros:
Great for small businesses and “Instagram” shops
Easy and fast to set up for non-techy users
Good for those focused on marketing and brands rather than complex ecommerce
Cons:
GDPR issues. can be problematic for EU customers
Restrictions on sensitive products: Not ideal for items like sex toys, gambling, or vaping etc - Shopify tracks everything and payment providers are also problematic
High pricing: Not suitable for larger eCommerce businesses due to fees
If you sell much you can quickly hit 2-3k fees or more per month - therefore you could also hire a woo dev
Extra costs: You often need additional apps for more features, which adds up
Template uniformity: Many stores look similar unless you can customize them or can develop
SureCart
Pros:
Excellent for digital products and memberships
Simple setup for selling digital goods
Cons:
Limited Third-Party support: Not as many integrations as WooCommerce or Shopify
Developer needed: Connecting to ERP/CRM solutions usually requires a developer
WooCommerce
Pros:
Highly customizable and flexible
No tracking, which is great for privacy
More cost-effective for larger stores in the long run
Cons:
Setup complexity: Can be a hassle to get started, especially for non-tech users
Hosting and maintenance: You’re responsible for these, which can be daunting
Need some plugins for that extra sauce
In summary:
If you want something quick and easy, go with Shopify.
For digital products, SureCart is great.
But if you need flexibility and control, WooCommerce is the way to go, even if it takes more effort to set up.